Forum |

Hard Arrangement Riddle

posted by pinguhash
- June 03 2011 02:01:43 AM

There was a woman suffering from Short-Term-Memory-Loss who was suspecting her servant of stealing things from her house. She brought 28 bottles of wine and arranged them on sides of square box in such a way that on each side no. of bottles are 9 and she wrote 9 in her diary. Afterwards the servant(cunning kid) stole 4 bottles and arranged them in such a way that still on each side total no. of bottles are 9. And again after some days he stole 4 bottles and arranged such that no. of bottles on side is still 9.

How he did that?

(Legends:- no.=number)

How he did that?

(Legends:- no.=number)

Reply by Caprico
- June 03 2011 09:53:08 AM

Firstly, how did she arrange 28 bottles in that way? The minimum bottles you'd need to have an arrangement like that is 36 (with no common bottle) and 32 (With each side sharing the corner bottle). Please help with just the question, I'll try figure the answer out after that...

Reply by Ragib
- June 03 2011 10:04:34 AM

first keep 2 bottles in each corner(one above another).then take 4 away.this time keep 3 bottles each corner.then,keep 4 bottles each corner and problem solved.

Reply by pinguhash
- June 03 2011 10:06:34 AM

You are indirectly asking the amswer. How she arranged 28 bottles is part of question.

Hint: Bottles at corner are common for 2 sides.

Hint: Bottles at corner are common for 2 sides.

Reply by pinguhash
- June 03 2011 10:07:33 AM

Yes ragib is correct

Reply by Ragib
- June 03 2011 10:07:56 AM

i can balance more than one bottle each corner.

Reply by Caprico
- June 03 2011 10:09:35 AM

Even if they are common for two sides. Try drawing it out. 9+9+7+7 = 32. Otherwise, Ragib's solution is right.

Reply by Ragib
- June 03 2011 10:13:16 AM

oh!caprico couldn't find this out!that's human.but 0! answer was awesome.i couldn't figure that out.but according to the definition of factorial,i totally disagree that 0! is 1.

Reply by pinguhash
- June 03 2011 10:15:19 AM

Here is the solution:

Woman arrangment: 2 5 2 each side

Servant arrangment: 3 3 3 each side

Servant arr. II : 4 1 4

I think now you wont confuse

Woman arrangment: 2 5 2 each side

Servant arrangment: 3 3 3 each side

Servant arr. II : 4 1 4

I think now you wont confuse

Reply by Caprico
- June 03 2011 10:23:49 AM

@Ragib, Thank you very much... :D And We think alike! I asked the same doubt to my professor, and he's a very very intelligent man, solves the most complex of problems in seconds in his mind. He says that 0!=1 is not for us to contemplate, it is defined that way. :P

Reply by Ragib
- June 03 2011 11:17:32 AM

rule is rule,bro!but i hate rules.

To post a response, simply log in with your Google Account.

Log in | Desktop Site |